Learning Objectives
- Explain the difference between casual listeners, referential listeners, critical listeners, and perceptive listeners.
- Discuss the casual listener's approach to music and the use of certain pieces of music, e.g., Johann Sebastian Bach's Air from Suite No. 3 in D major, BWV 1068, as background or mood music.
- Discuss the referential listener's approach to music and the use of certain pieces of music, e.g., Hector Berlioz's Symphonie Fantastique, as program music.
- Discuss the critical listener's motivation to music listening and how her/his approach differs from that of the casual and the referentiallistener.
- Discuss the perceptive listener's approach to music listening and how their listening attitude combines, but is not limited by that of the casual, referential, and critical listener.
- Explain the difference between program music and absolute music.
- Review Berlioz's Symphonie Fantastique and Vivaldi's The Four Seasons (Le Quattro Stagioni) as examples of program music.
- Define the following musical terms: absolute music, ideé fixe, program music, symphony, tempo, and theme.
Types of Listeners
The Critical Listener
A critical listener's primary motivation is to identify what is wrong with a performance. For very scrupulous critical listeners, every detail of the performance must be perfect, including the accuracy of the notes. Such listeners may even demand perfection in live music, with anything short of perfection considered a poor performance.
Holding music to high artistic and technical standards is not unreasonable. However, listeners ought to consider the differences between live performances and synthetic, perfected recordings that have been edited to eliminate mistakes. In live performances, mistakes occur. Performers miss notes, instruments go out of tune, and there are noises and distractions from the audience. Concentrating on technical perfection while ignoring other aspects of a musical performance may detract from the music, and it often keeps the listener from wholly enjoying the music and what it has to offer.
Furthermore, the piece's purpose may not coincide with the critical listener's motivation. When a mother sings a lullaby to put a child to sleep, the quality of a performance must be judged not by musical standards, but on the basis of whether or not the song has put the child to sleep. It is not important if the mother does not sing every note perfectly so long as the other elements, such as hushed volume, steady speed (tempo), and a big dose of tenderness, are present.
Guide
A la nana, a la bubaSe durma la criatura
El Dio grande que los guardeA los niños de los males
A la nana, a la bubaSe durma la criatura
Composer: Anonymous
-
"A la nana"
The Perceptive Listener
The last listener type, the perceptive listener, combines the characteristics of the previous three types of listeners but is not limited by them. The perceptive listener does the following:
- Like the casual listener, this person enjoys sound for sound's sake, but asks what is it in the music that makes me feel this way:
- Is it the way the performer is interpreting the music?
- Is it because of the volume or speed at which it is played?
- Is it because it is sung, played by instruments, or because it has a good balance of unity and variety?
- Is it a combination of all these elements?
- If so, which combination is at work?
- Like the referential listener, this person may have associations with the music being heard, but also tries to remember:
- when and where the music was heard most recently and
- what other works from that composer or performer she knows.
- Like the critical listener, this person is aware of the quality of a performance but goes beyond the technical aspects to seek understanding and appreciation of the human and cultural values embodied in the music.
Furthermore, the perceptive listener:
- attends concerts regularly and listens with concentration;
- uses appropriate musical vocabulary, not lay terms like “mellow” or “upbeat,” to describe music;
- tries to develop an awareness of different musical styles and realizes that there are significant and valid differences among these styles;
- realizes that music is created for many different purposes and by many different kinds of people;
- tries to understand the music and what makes it interesting before passing judgment on it;
- would never decide to dislike a certain kind of music without having listened to it;
- tries to learn something about the music before listening to a live or recorded performance of it; and
- is aware of the fact that a piece of music, regardless of style, might take some time to reveal its structure, meaning and beauty, and is therefore prepared to reserve judgment until hearing it many times.
As you listen to the following piece, reflect on the following questions:
- Is there anything in this music that reminds you of winter?
- How does the composer create mood in this piece?
- What gives unity and variety to this piece?
Antonio Vivaldi's Concerto in F minor—one of four compositions that, as a group, form a work called The Four Seasons—is titled "Winter." Fine examples of program music, each of the four compositions depicts one of the four seasons of the year. Vivaldi was inspired by four paintings of the seasons by Marco Ricci (1676–1730), a prolific Italian artist who specialized in naturalistic landscape painting. Although it's not known who exactly wrote them, four poems (sonnets) accompany each movement. Vivaldi linked lines of the poems to specific sections of the music. Below, the sonnet that corresponds to the winter. Winter brings cold winds,the stamping of feet, and chattering teeth. Because this is program music, listen for how the music suggests winter and what specific words in the text might correspond to sections in the music. But remember: you may also try to listen for the musical structure of the work.
Composer: Antonio Vivaldi
-
"The Four Seasons, Violin Concerto in F Minor, Op. 8 No. 4, RV 297 "
Italian
Allegro non molto
Aggiacciato tremar trà nevi algenti
Al Severo Spirar d' orrido Vento,
Correr battendo i piedi ogni momento;
E pel Soverchio gel batter i denti;
Largo: La Pioggia
Passar al foco i di quieti e contenti
Mentre la pioggia fuor bagna ben cento
Allegro
Caminar Sopra il giaccio, e à passo lento
Per timor di cader girsene intenti;
Gir forte Sdruzziolar, cader à terra
Di nuove ir Sopra 'l giaccio e correr forte
Sin ch' il giaccio si rompe, e si disserra;
Sentir uscir dalle ferrate porte
Sirocco, Borea, e tutti i Venti in guerra
Quest' é 'l verno, mà tal, che gioja apporte.
English
Allegro non molto
To tremble from cold in the icy snow,
In the harsh breath of a horrid wind;
To run, stamping one's feet every moment,
Our teeth chattering in the extreme cold
Largo: The Rain
Before the fire to pass peaceful,
Contented days while the rain outside pours down.
Allegro
To walk on the ice and, at a slow pace
(For fear of falling), move carefully.
To make a bold turn, clip, fall down.
To go on the ice once more and run hard
Until the ice cracks and breaks up.
To hear the hot desert wind, the cold North Wind, and all
The winds at war leave their iron gates;
This is winter, but, even so, what joy it brings!